Previous slide
Next slide

Mystery Bargain Box

(15 customer reviews)

Mystery selection boxes of brownies and bakes at a bargain price!  You will get a large box of slices/cookies – the number received will vary depending on the size but we are always generous!  They may include broken bits, offcuts and full-size spare bits!  No fancy wrapping!

Please note: these are gluten-free but will not be suitable for sufferers of any other allergy as they may contain any products.  They do not come with an ingredient list or menu.  We are unable to offer nut-free or vegan versions as all the offcuts and spares are stored together.

£1 from every box goes to our local food bank.  NO PRE-ORDERS FOR MYSTERY BOXES PLEASE!

£12.00

Out of stock

Standard delivery 2-4 days – £3.99
Upgraded delivery 2-3 days – £5.99
Pick your estimated delivery date at checkout – please note this is an estimate and not guaranteed.
Click here for more info about delivery

You will receive a menu and full allergens and ingredients list with your brownies.  To see these before purchasing, please see ingredients below.

Find answers to all our FAQs here!

Our brownies and bakes are packed full of chocolate, which gives them a shelf life of a good 10 days on arrival.  Keep them wrapped up tight, or freeze if you want to keep them longer!

Mix a Mug kits will have a minimum of 3 months shelflife when you receive them.

Read more…

Additional Information

A mystery mix of brownies/cookies, no fancy wrapping!  May include a mix of shop specials, monthly specials and sneak previews of new specials!  You will get 5-6 slices (or 10-12) depending on the size of the slices! Grab yourself a bargain, first come first served, whilst stocks last! Please note – these may contain any flavours and ALL ALLERGENS and you can’t pick the selection.  Each box will vary and will not come with a menu card.  Brownies for good are subject to availability and cannot be bulk-ordered as corporate gifts. May contain marshmallows therefore will not be suitable for vegetarians.

Ingredients

Made in a bakery that handles MILK, EGGS, SOYA, NUTS & PEANUTS therefore may contain any of these allergens. Please be aware that amongst other allergens, this box may also contain coconut or oats.

Unsuitable for vegans and vegetarians due to the nature of the box.

15 reviews for Mystery Bargain Box

  1. Lisa McIntyre

    Absolutely amazing! As a previous customer i have items I love, but the mystery box meant to go to try things I wouldn’t usually order…and the carrot and pecan blondie we got in our mystery box…was actually AMAZING! Will be looking out for this going back on the menu!! And as always, every single item was just delicious! Thank you for being gluten free! I’m so glad i found you guys!

  2. C. Robertson

    I’ve ordered a few of these now and they never disappoint. Everything I’ve had has been delicious! Great if you’re buying for yourself or a family treat and not bothered about the packaging

  3. Gill Scowcroft

    Bought these Mystery boxes twice after purchasing other beautiful brownies for gifts and to share.
    I love the surprise element of the boxes. Our first one had some Coronation specials in it. They are certainly excellent value and the contents are guaranteed to be delicious every time from Simply Cake. Prompt delivery too.

  4. Cathy Saunders

    Absolute bargain. You can’t go wrong ‘cos every flavour brownie or cookie you get is delicious.

  5. Sarah Bowden

    Hide it from the kids!
    Having tried a few different flavours of the brownies and cookies I have no fear in ‘risking it’ with a mystery box. I must admit I justified the order without any special occasion in mind on the basis that it was for the children as a treat. Who was I kidding, it arrived quickly and I was not disappointed. I cut a couple of the them in half to let the kids try and then hid the rest to enjoy with a cuppa while they were at school. I can’t recommend these enough, an indulgent treat you deserve.

  6. Katherine

    The mystery bargain box is amazing value for money and filled with tasty treats. I loved mine and often am not quick enough to order another as they get snapped up fast! I do wish there was a card with the flavours on so I could check if my guesses are correct, but regardless they are just divine. And all gluten free! Yay.

  7. Pauline

    This mystery box is such a treat and a brilliant bargain. We we delighted with the selection in our surprise box, and will definitely order again. Oh and they freeze so well!

  8. Morna

    Great value box for a treat for yourself. Have never come across a flavour I didn’t like – even had some I definitely wouldn’t have ordered out of choice that I’ve tried in a mystery box and are now firm faves!

  9. Phoebe

    I have bought these boxes on multiple occasions, and I have always been blown away by the quantity and quality of the brownies/blondies and cookies.

    If you are unsure of what product to try, I would recommend buying one of these boxes as it gives you chance to try a range of products. The only problem is, you have to be quick as the fly off the website fast!!

  10. Lucy

    Great Value
    I love that. Portion of the money goes to the local food bank
    I have purchased a few of these and sent them to friends and family
    Still hoping someone will send me one 😁

  11. Lisa McIntyre

    My second box was just as amazing as my first! Love the variety and trying things I wouldn’t usually order! Yet to find anything i don’t like! And as a coeliac it’s nice to be able to have a cakey treat without worrying!

  12. Mandy

    Great selection of brownies and cookies , fantastic value if your looking for a bargain treat .

  13. Bec

    Amazing as usual, I love the fact you can try so many different flavours of cookies/ brownies/ cake pops!!

  14. Emma

    Tasty mix of items! Thing I wouldn’t have tried without this :), very good value for money and also good knowing £1 is going towards the food bank.

  15. Tina

    Bought the mystery box as a bit of a January cheer up and my goodness what a treat!everything was delicious especially the blondies,gorgeous.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Customers Also Bought

BROWSE

Browse our website and pick from our huge range of delicious bakes.

Personalise

Why not add a gift message for that personal touch? It's free!

Fast Letterbox Delivery

Choose your delivery option: Upgraded 2-3 working days or Standard 3-5 working days!

Put Your Feet Up

..and wait for your delivery! We're busy behind the scenes making fudgy brownies that won't disappoint!

BROWSE

Browse our website and pick from our huge range of delicious bakes.

Personalise

Why not add a gift message for that personal touch? It's free!

Fast Letterbox Delivery

Choose your delivery option: Upgraded 2-3 working days or Standard 3-5 working days!

Put Your Feet Up

..and wait for your delivery! We're busy behind the scenes making fudgy brownies that won't disappoint!

As Seen In